Top 25 All-Time You Pick’em Wins Leaders:
| Contestants | W | L | Pct |
| tone84 | 1030 | 244 | 80.85% |
| YODA MASTER | 1023 | 245 | 80.68% |
| JK | 1010 | 264 | 79.28% |
| Warrior Wideouts | 1009 | 264 | 79.26% |
| peezy28 | 912 | 242 | 79.03% |
| lattimo | 904 | 291 | 75.65% |
| MARDUK | 901 | 355 | 71.74% |
| BOCEPHUS | 881 | 250 | 77.90% |
| wac05 | 868 | 299 | 74.38% |
| livingnexile | 823 | 229 | 78.23% |
| jerrys907 | 807 | 346 | 69.99% |
| Lanness | 779 | 205 | 79.17% |
| Zmilliro | 759 | 282 | 72.91% |
| JD1987 | 734 | 240 | 75.36% |
| WarriorsFan | 722 | 149 | 82.89% |
| WARRIOR | 670 | 238 | 73.79% |
| EBHS | 647 | 229 | 73.86% |
| DX | 640 | 357 | 64.19% |
| CCCDad | 633 | 195 | 76.45% |
| thegame48 | 525 | 207 | 71.72% |
| football4eva | 503 | 161 | 75.75% |
| DHSDogs1995 | 489 | 124 | 79.77% |
| rob_pt | 473 | 147 | 76.29% |
| ALL-IN | 434 | 132 | 76.68% |
| Route_runner22 | 405 | 152 | 72.71% |
Top 25 All-Time You Pick’em Winning Percentage Leaders (min 400 games played):
| Contestants | Pct | W | L | Wins/Pct: closest Pick’em Players in same gms |
| tsnk4040 | 82.96% | 370 | 76 | WF +6 W (84.30%), LVGNEX tied W (82.96%) |
| WarriorsFan | 82.89% | 722 | 149 | TONE -18 W (80.83%), YODA -22 W (80.74%) |
| Gulfcoast Nole | 82.29% | 367 | 79 | WF +9 W (84.30%), TSNK/LVGNEX +3 W(82.96%) |
| tone84 | 80.85% | 1030 | 244 | YODA -7 W (80.68%), JK -20 W (79.28%) |
| YODA MASTER | 80.68% | 1023 | 245 | TONE +7 W (80.85%), JK -13 W (79.28%) |
| ravematic101 | 80.60% | 378 | 91 | WF +20 W (84.86%), +11 LVGNEX (82.94%) |
| DHSDogs1995 | 79.77% | 489 | 124 | |
| JK | 79.28% | 1010 | 264 | |
| Warrior Wideouts | 79.26% | 1009 | 264 | |
| Lanness | 79.17% | 779 | 205 | |
| peezy28 | 79.03% | 912 | 242 | |
| livingnexile | 78.23% | 823 | 229 | |
| BOCEPHUS | 77.90% | 881 | 250 | |
| El Vaquero | 77.38% | 390 | 114 | |
| huliman88 | 77.00% | 328 | 98 | |
| ALL-IN | 76.68% | 434 | 132 | |
| CCCDad | 76.45% | 633 | 195 | |
| rob_pt | 76.29% | 473 | 147 | |
| football4eva | 75.75% | 503 | 161 | |
| lattimo | 75.65% | 904 | 291 | |
| JD1987 | 75.36% | 734 | 240 | |
| wac05 | 74.38% | 868 | 299 | |
| EBHS | 73.86% | 647 | 229 | |
| WARRIOR | 73.79% | 670 | 238 | |
| The Fan | 72.94% | 399 | 148 |
You Pick’em Overall Winners by Year:
| Contestants | Year | Wins | Losses | PCT |
| WarriorsFan | 2012 | 376 | 70 | 84.3% |
| WarriorsFan | 2011 | 314 | 72 | 81.4% |
| JK | 2010 | 186 | 41 | 81.9% |
| tone84 | 2009 | 174 | 41 | 80.9% |
You Pick’em Playoff Winners by Year:
| Contestants | Year | Wins | Losses | PCT |
| ravematic101 | 2012 | 38 | 9 | 80.9% |
| tone84 | 2011 | 50 | 13 | 79.4% |
| WARRIOR | 2010 | 33 | 6 | 84.6% |
| YODA MASTER | 2009 | 35 | 7 | 83.3% |